Is It a Pie, a Cake, or Maybe a… Donut?

lose-up of two cream-filled doughnuts topped with shiny chocolate glaze, arranged on a white plate. Pale yellow custard filling peeks out from the sides, and the image is softly lit with a neutral, out-of-focus background.

It Depends

The answer depends on which Massachusetts dessert you’re talking about.

The Bay State has given us everything from Boston Cream Pie and the chocolate chip cookie to Fig Newtons and Boston cream donuts. Some were created in elegant hotel dining rooms, others in inns and bakeries, but all have become part of the American dessert landscape.

Just a quick list is loaded with icons of the dessert world:

  • Chocolate Chip Cookies (better known as Toll House Cookies)
  • Fig Newtons
  • Sky Bars
  • Junior Mints

And then there’s the Boston Cream Pie.

Chocolate drip cake with creamy filling displayed on a glass cake stand in a kitchen setting.

This sweet treat has spent most of its life struggling to find its identity. It’s called a pie, but it looks like a cake. Then someone turned it into a donut, and suddenly you could hold a little piece of heaven in your hand.

Close-up of a cream-filled doughnut topped with glossy chocolate icing, held between fingers as rich custard filling oozes from a large bite. Several other chocolate-covered doughnuts sit softly blurred in the background on parchment paper.Think about it: rich creamy vanilla filling tucked inside a soft, pillowy donut and topped with a smooth chocolate glaze. Messy? Maybe. Delicious? Absolutely.

Chefs at the Parker House Hotel, now known as the Omni Parker House,  developed the original Boston Cream Pie. It seems they’re experts at creating foods that stand the test of time. After all, we’ve all heard of Parker House Rolls. They were a must-have at many family gatherings, especially Thanksgiving. The hotel is also known for Boston Scrod, a classic New England fish dish featuring our native cod, or sometimes haddock

But getting back to our confused dessert…

Over the years, it has appeared on menus under several different names, including American Pudding Pie and Chocolate Cream Pie. At one point it was even known as American Pudding Cake Pie. Now that’s a mouthful.

It’s said that some of the confusion came from the pans used to bake it. Back in the day, cakes were often baked in pie tins. Somewhere along the way, the name stuck while the dessert evolved. If you think about it that way, it’s really a cake pretending to be a pie.

Or maybe it’s a little bit of both.

And thanks to the Boston Cream donut, perhaps it’s part donut, too.

Pie. Cake. Donut.

Whatever you call it, it’s delicious.

Martini Anyone?A Boston Cream Pie martini served in a stemmed cocktail glass, featuring a creamy vanilla-colored base topped with a thick layer of glossy chocolate that drips down the rim. A fresh mint leaf garnishes the drink. The martini sits on a red serving tray alongside two chocolate-covered pastry bites sprinkled with chopped nuts. Part of a Boston cream pastry is visible in the background against a dark backdrop.

Today, you can even enjoy a Boston Cream Martini at the Parker House bar. For a dessert that can’t decide what it wants to be, that’s quite an accomplishment.

And it just keeps getting better. As if pie, cake, and donut weren’t enough, I recently discovered Boston Cream Pie Cookies. They look suspiciously like moon pies.

 It seems this Massachusetts classic continues to reinvent itself. At this point, the Boston Cream Pie may be the most confused dessert in Massachusetts.

A Boston cream pie cookie sits on a small plate, layered with rich vanilla cream filling and covered in a thick drizzle of dark chocolate ganache. Several matching cookies are displayed on a platter in the background.

Making a Boston Cream Pie from scratch can be a bit of a project. You’ve got the vanilla sponge cake, the pastry cream filling, and the chocolate ganache topping. That’s a lot of steps for one dessert.

So for those of you who are feeling adventurous, I’m going to link to a recipe from Preppy Kitchen. They even have a YouTube video that walks you through the entire process.

If you decide to make one, let me know how it turns out.

As for me, I think I’ll save myself the effort and stop at my local Dunkin’ for a dozen Boston Cream donuts.

Enjoy! 😊

Boston cream pie with chocolate-glazed top, custard filling, and toasted almond-covered sides, displayed on a white cake stand with one slice removed.

Ghosts in the Graveyard

Halloween-themed banner featuring an orange background with black silhouettes of haunted houses, bats, and a full moon. In the foreground, a glowing blue ghost decoration stands beside two orange tabby cat figurines wearing witch hats. Black decorative fence posts frame the scene, creating a festive Halloween display with warm orange lighting and spooky accents.

alloween-themed chocolate pudding cups topped with crushed cookie "dirt," white ghost-shaped whipped cream decorations with candy eyes, and small tombstone cookies labeled "RIP." Several dessert cups are arranged on a light-colored surface, creating a playful spooky cemetery effect.Here we are. It’s almost Halloween!

Are you going to a party? Are you hosting one? Do you need a special dessert for this spooky time of year?

Here’s one last ghostly recipe. You might say I saved the best for last. It’s one of my favorites, and the nice thing is that you can make individual servings in plastic cups or one large dessert in a 13 × 9-inch baking dish.

 

So, without further ado, I give you…

Ghosts in a Graveyard

Ingredients

  • 2 packages (3.9 oz. each) instant chocolate puddingHalloween-themed dessert decorated to look like a graveyard. A metal baking pan is filled with dark chocolate crumb topping resembling soil, with cookie tombstones decorated with black crosses standing throughout the dessert. White ghost-shaped frosting figures, small orange pumpkin candies, and pieces of candy corn are scattered across the surface. The dessert is photographed from an angled overhead view against a light background.
  • 3 cups cold milk
  • 1 tub (12 oz.) Cool Whip topping, thawed and divided
  • 15 Oreo cookies, crushed (about 1½ cups)
  • Assorted decorations: 3 cream sandwich cookies, decorating gel, candy pumpkins, candy corn, gummy worms, ghost peeps and any other spooky candies you can think of

Directions

  1. Beat the pudding mix and milk in a large bowl for 2 minutes. Let stand for 5 minutes.
  2. Stir in 3 cups of the Cool Whip and half of the cookie crumbs. Spread in a 13 × 9-inch baking dish and sprinkle with the remaining cookie crumbs.For individual servings, divide the pudding mixture among plastic cups and top with the cookie crumbs.
  3. Refrigerate for 1 hour. Meanwhile, decorate the cream sandwich cookies with decorating gel to resemble tombstones.
  4. Insert the decorated cookies into the pudding. Add candies as desired. Use the remaining Cool Whip to make ghosts by dropping spoonfuls on top.

Halloween-themed graveyard dessert in a white baking dish, topped with crushed chocolate cookie "dirt," marshmallow ghosts, cookie tombstones decorated with "RIP" in chocolate, candy corn, gummy worms, and small pumpkin candies. An orange ghost-shaped cookie with a jack-o'-lantern face stands near the front, while additional ghost and tombstone decorations fill the dessert, creating a colorful and playful spooky scene.

Notes

This recipe makes 18 servings, so plan on using 18 plastic cups if you’re making individual servings.

Around our house, we call them Boo Cups!

Baked Alaska The Dessert, Not The State

  
A large lakeside resort complex on Green Island in Lake George, New York, featuring white buildings with brown roofs, outdoor pools, landscaped grounds, and a long dock extending into the lake. The resort is surrounded by dense green forest and distant mountains under a clear sky.

Growing Up a Resort Town Kid

Here we go again, falling down the nostalgia rabbit hole.

A friend of mine posted some vacation photos on Instagram, and one of them was captioned Sagamore Hotel. I immediately dropped him a note: Is that the Sagamore on Lake George? The one on Green Island in Bolton Landing?

When he said yes, they were vacationing there, I of course responded, That’s my hometown! Not the Sagamore itself, of course, but Bolton Landing. To this day it still surprises me when anyone says they know where it is. Everyone has heard of Lake George, but not Bolton Landing.

But I’m getting off track.

The Sagamore was a big convention hotel when I was growing up. They catered to business conferences, and then came the “social season,” when the rich folks from New York City arrived to enjoy the lake. That’s how us locals thought of them. After all, we couldn’t afford to stay at The Sagamore — so obviously the people who did must be rich, right? It was just one of those unspoken small‑town truths.

A spacious hotel lobby with rustic décor, featuring a large round wooden table with decorative vases, comfortable seating areas with earth‑tone armchairs and sofas, stone tile flooring, framed photos on the wall, and a mounted deer head creating a cozy lodge‑style atmosphere.

 

I had a summer job working with the local photographer. Mostly it meant sitting in the lobby next to a display board of photos and taking orders, but occasionally he’d bring me along for banquet night as his assistant. My job was simple: keep the film cartridges loaded and ready to hand over fast. This was especially important when the banquet started.

 

 

All the diners would be seated, and then the kitchen doors swung open. White‑suited chefs and waiters paraded in with huge trays balanced on their shoulders. And coming up the rear was the pièce de résistance — the flaming Baked Alaska. It was always quite a spectacle.

  
A row of formally dressed servers carrying dome‑shaped Baked Alaska desserts with browned meringue and small blue flames on top, presenting them in a coordinated procession during a banquet. The warm lighting and flames create a dramatic, celebratory atmosphere.

I had no idea then what Baked Alaska actually was, except that it was a dessert that made a grand entrance in flames. Imagine my surprise when I eventually learned it was basically ice cream. What? Doesn’t it melt?

I’m older now and a bit more kitchen‑wise, but I still don’t know if I’m brave enough to try this retro dessert.

Are you?

A Little History Before We Get to the Recipe

Baked Alaska goes all the way back to the mid‑1800s, when chefs were experimenting with the science of heat insulation. The idea was almost comical: wrap ice cream in a thick layer of meringue, then blast it with high heat. The meringue acts like a fluffy winter coat, protecting the frozen center.

The dessert became famous at Delmonico’s Restaurant in New York City, where chef Charles Ranhofer originallyA close-up slice of Baked Alaska showing layers of sponge cake, chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry ice cream, all covered in a thick coating of toasted meringue with golden-brown peaks. called it Alaska, Florida — cold inside, hot outside. Over time the name evolved into Baked Alaska, and restaurants began presenting it with full theatrical flair: dimmed lights, flaming rum, and waiters parading it through the dining room like royalty.

That’s the version I saw at the Sagamore — the classic banquet‑hall Baked Alaska, flaming and dramatic and absolutely unforgettable.

But the classic version is… well… a production. So here’s a simplified, home‑friendly version that gives you the magic without the stress.

🍨 Simplified Baked Alaska (Home-Friendly Version)

Ingredients

  • 1 pound cake (store‑bought works perfectly)
  • 1 pint ice cream (any flavor you love)
  • 3 large egg whites
  • ½ cup sugar
  • ½ teaspoon vanilla extract
  • Pinch of salt

Instructions

  1. Prepare the base: Cut the pound cake into a circle or square slightly larger than your ice cream dome. Place it on a parchment‑lined baking sheet.
  2. Add the ice cream: Scoop the ice cream into a rounded mound on top of the cake. Freeze for at least 1 hour so it’s firm.
  3. Make the meringue: Beat egg whites and salt until foamy. Gradually add sugar and vanilla. Continue beating until stiff, glossy peaks form.
  4. Cover completely: Spread the meringue over the ice cream and cake, making sure it’s sealed with no gaps. This insulation is what keeps the ice cream from melting.
  5. Bake quickly: Bake at 500°F for 3–5 minutes, just until the meringue is golden. (Or use a kitchen torch for even easier browning.)
  6. Serve immediately: Slice and enjoy the magic — warm meringue outside, cold ice cream inside.

A dome-shaped Baked Alaska covered in toasted meringue with golden-brown peaks, sitting on a decorative plate with fresh strawberries blurred in the background.

Final Thoughts

So there you have it — a little Baked Alaska nostalgia. It’s one of those retro desserts that deserves a comeback. Meringue and ice cream? Yes, please.